Showing posts with label Nonprofit Leadership. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Nonprofit Leadership. Show all posts

Wednesday, April 26, 2017

Valuing People as People


“Diversity” has many definitions: some include differences in gender, race/ethnicity, age; others cover differences in attitudes, perspectives, and backgrounds; still others generalize to “all the ways in which we differ” (Robinson, 2). My favorite defines “diversity” not just as a result, but as a process, a way of thinking: diversity is “valuing, respecting, and appreciating the differences that make people unique” (McNett, 1). This definition transcends viewing traits, characteristics, perspectives or values to suggest valuing people as unique people.

As the world continues to grow ever more interconnected, embracing this view of diversity becomes increasingly important. Many feel diversity in the workplace is “just the right thing to do” or that “discrimination is wrong” (McNett; Thomas). In my mind, it’s not just right, it’s the only thing to do–view and value people as people.

The benefits of diversity in an organization transcend these ethical considerations. Studies show a more diverse workforce benefits an organization’s effectiveness (Thomas). A diverse workforce can increase an organizations capacity for learning, creativity, flexibility, and ultimately growth (Thomas). These benefits extend to increasing an organization’s ability to rapidly adjust to ever-changing communities (Thomas).

Some leaders encourage diverse groups to blend in or value diversity only for the increased knowledge an employee has about his/her identity group (Thomas). However, in order to realize the benefits of diversity, organizations and their leaders need to shift from defining diversity as membership in this or that identity group. In fact, pursuing diversity initiatives with this mindset may actually backfire, heightening tensions among employees and hindering performance (Thomas).

Instead, leaders must consider diversity to include valuing the varied perspectives and approaches that unique people bring (Thomas). A diverse workforce contributes diverse perspectives to reconsider how and why organizations design processes, reach goals, and communicate ideas; in other words, diversity provides fresh and meaningful approaches (Thomas).

However, leaders cannot be passive observers, expecting diversity to fall in their laps. A leader must also ensure the organization has a clear and understood mission which helps guide discussions about changes, centering around goals (Thomas). A leader and organization must recognize barriers to application processes that may inhibit diversity in who applies to an organization. Leaders can also encourage employees to self-reflect. Increasing self-awareness can be a powerful step towards valuing diversity, in recognizing your own strengths and assets, but also in understanding how your actions affect others or might be perceived by others.

To position an organization that participates in such thinking requires working to create a culture that supports and values diversity, including creating a culture that (Thomas):
o   has high standards of performance for everyone.
o   stimulates personal development.
o   encourages openness.
o   makes workers feel valued.
o   promotes exchange of ideas/ welcomes constructive challenges.

Ultimately, diversity integration requires a long-term commitment that embraces learning and valuing diverse perspectives and views (Robinson). Doing so can have positive benefits like increased employee buy-in and engagement (Thomas). More importantly, it can help an organization leverage the diverse talent pool to impact both short-term and long-term performance and help improve the organization’s impact.

Sources:
McNett, Jeanne. “Diversity in the Workplace: Ethics, Pragmatism, or Some of Both?” Understanding and Managing Diversity. Prentice Hall.

Robinson, Gail, Dechant, Kathleen. “Building a Business for Diversity”. Understanding and Managing Diversity. Prentice Hall.

Sowell, Thomas. “A World View of Cultural Diversity”. Understanding and Managing Diversity. Prentice Hall.

Thomas, David A., Ely, Robin J. “Making Differences Matter: A New Paradigm for Managing Diversity”. Understanding and Managing Diversity. Prentice Hall.



Diversity is Good for Business

            Astute business leaders are already considering that the changing face of the nation also represents the changing face of business. They understand that to thrive both domestically and globally, being multicultural is essential. In focusing on the domestic front, consider for example, that:

·       The biggest demographic change in the United States is the rise of the majority-minority; 92% of U.S. population growth is attributed to ethnic groups, while the growth in the working-age population will be as much as 83 percent (Loehr, 2015).

·       By 2020, minorities are projected to make up 40 percent of the civilian labor force (Loehr, 2015).

            While ethnic diversity is unquestionably an essential component of a diversified workforce, “creating a work environment that values diversity is not as simple as hiring individuals with a range of skin tones and language skills” (Na, 2015). Instead, by diversity we mean “valuing, respecting, and appreciating the differences (such as age, culture, education, ethnicity, experience, gender, race, religion, and sexual orientation, among others) that make people unique” (McNett, 2005).

Benefits of Diversity

            One benefit of diversity is that organizations that recognize its importance will be able to compete more effectively for qualified individuals, enhancing their very survival. Indeed, companies that are leading the way in embracing diversity already have come to understand that “when you have a homogeneous company, it can be very difficult to get diverse candidates to even apply” (Gaudiano and Hunt, 2017).

            The imperative to rework human resources strategies with diversity in mind, further stems from the growing recognition that “only in an environment of diverse perspectives, human experiences, and thinking styles can the conversations that generate the insight and new ideas required for innovation be sparked” (Na, 2015). That is, “diverse work groups often have more and better ideas because of broader backgrounds and experiences” (Kokemuller, 2017).

            Moreover, “workplaces in which employees represent the basic makeup of the community population are typically better received by customers and the public (Kokemuller, 2017). The same holds true for companies working with global markets, as ethnic and cultural diversity often provides them with a better understanding of their global customers.

Managing Diversity

            There is no single approach to working with diversity. “It is not only how a company defines diversity, but what it does with the experiences of being a diverse organization, that delivers on the promise” (Thomas and Ely, 1996). Foremost to improved outcomes is the need to obtain top management support and integrate diversity into all company functions. Beyond these initial steps, the best strategies for working with diversity are (Wentling, 1997):

  • training and education programs
  • organizational policies that mandate fairness and equity for all employees
  • mentoring programs for minority employees
  • more systematic career guidance and planning programs
  • performance appraisal systems that are non-discriminatory
  • outreach programs, such as internship programs, scholarships, targeting recruitment in the community, and lectures at schools.

            Importantly, all forms of training should include awareness-building, skill development, application, and support (Wentling, 1997). Creating a corporate culture that supports diversity is especially important, as the “potential benefits of training will not be likely to occur unless trainees return to a supportive environment for applying what they have learned” (Wentling, 1997).

           Company leaders who are cultivating diversity in their workplace clearly understand the benefits, including improved employee recruitment, innovation, and connectedness with diverse consumer groups.  However, because of the growing diversity in our society, the ability of U.S. companies to leverage the incredible resource that those who are ‘different’ can offer is becoming ever more urgent.

 References

Gaudiano, P and Hunt, E.  (2017, April 10). The Top Eight Excuses that Inhibit Workplace Diversity. Forbes.  Retrieved from: https://www.forbes.com/sites/gaudianohunt/2017/04/10/the-top-eight-excuses-that-inhibit-workplace-diversity/#43cfedc24899

Kokemuller, N. (2017). What is Diversity and How Does It Impact Work?  Chron. Retrieved from: http://smallbusiness.chron.com/diversity-impact-work-15985.html

Loehr, A. (2015, April 22) These Four Workplace Trends Will Change Your Organization: Are You Ready? [Web log post]. Retrieved from: http://www.anneloehr.com/2015/04/22/four-workplace-trends/

McNett, J. (2005) Diversity in The Workplace: Ethics, Pragmatism, Or Some of Both? Understanding and managing diversity: readings, cases, and exercises. - Upper Saddle River, N.J: Pearson Prentice Hall

Na, Y. (2015, June 30). Diversity in the workplace, no longer optional.  Flamingo.  Retrieved from: http://flamingogroup.com/diversity-in-the-workplace-no-longer-optional

Thomas, D.A. and Ely, R. (1996, September-October). Making Difference Matter: A New Paradigm for Managing Diversity. Harvard Business Review. Retrieved from: https://hbr.org/1996/09/making-differences-matter-a-new-paradigm-for-managing-diversity

Wentling, R. (1997, Summer). Diversity Initiatives in the Workplace: Work in Progress at the University of Illinois. CenterWork Volume 8, Number 2. Retrieved from http://ncrve.berkeley.edu/CW82/Diversity.html

Thursday, April 6, 2017

Where Does Collaborative Value Come From?


When it comes to the creation of value, not all collaborations are equal, as the Collaborative Value Creation (CVC) Framework reveals. The framework helps us understand how value creation can change as the partnering relationship evolves through the four stages of the Collaboration Continuum: philanthropic, transactional, integrative, and transformational (Renz 2016). The increased potential for value at each stage coincides with changes in three drivers of value: alignment, engagement, and leverage (Renz).

The philanthropic stage is the most common and traditional type of relationship (Austin 2003). The Timberland-City Year relationship started this way in 1989 when the youth service organization requested and received a donation of 50 pairs of boots from Timberland. Given the shared goal of community service, the relationship evolved into the transactional stage where Timberland employees were mobilized to participate with City Year in community service events. Key benefits of the synergism between the partner’s resources were increased business and visibility. In 1994, the collaboration evolved into a strategic alliance that included integration of the vision and values of both companies and the formation of a joint enterprise to create the City Year Gear product line of apparel and gear. In this integrative stage, the missions, strategies, organizations, and resources merged, and the collaboration took on the characteristics of a joint venture (Austin). While integration has much greater strategic value, it is more complex to manage than other forms of collaboration (Renz). In this case, an added complexity was the potential conflict of interest of the CEO of Timberland serving as the chair of the non-profit’s Board of Directors. Yet, the multifaceted form of engagement in this partnership points to a deeper commitment that will help to sustain the collaboration through challenges (Renz), including the financial setbacks that both entities experienced in 1994. 

While geared toward the nonprofit-business relationship, the Collaboration Continuum can also provide insights about the generation of value in nonprofit-nonprofit and nonprofit-government collaborations. 

The Seattle Art Museum-Housing First relationship, for example, was a nonprofit-nonprofit transactional collaboration. The organizations determined there was mutual benefit in cooperating on the “Citizens for a Better Seattle” capital campaign, rather than compete for project votes at the ballot box. The strategic importance of this relationship is limited to alignment on a single activity, though considerable value was derived from the ability to leverage available resources and assets. Increasing the strategic value of the partnership is hampered by mind-set of the partners, namely the lack of trust among housing advocates for their museum partners.     

On the nonprofit-government front, La Alianza Hispana, a “self-help alliance for Hispanics” is confronted with a take-it-or-leave-it contractual proposition from the Massachusetts Department of Social Services (DSS). Namely, the current transactional collaboration around the provision of “soft” services, would be replaced with a higher dollar value collaboration around the delivery child protection and case management services. In this case, an examination of value drivers points to the conclusion that La Alianza would be well advised not to enter into the proposed collaboration due to a lack of alignment on mission and lack of resources. While these challenges could potentially be overcome, we are told that DSS is limited in its ability to help La Alianza measure up to contractual expectations and that the DSS' proposed rate would not adequately cover legal and other overhead expenses.  

In summary, it is useful to consider how the stages in the Collaboration Continuum exhibit differences in strategic value, engagement level, importance to mission, and resource deployment (Austin). The organization’s stance on these strategic aspects can provide an important guide in organizational decision-making relative to the current and potential value of a collaborative relationship.

References

Renz, David O. The Jossey-Bass Handbook of Nonprofit Leadership and Management (Essential Texts for Nonprofit and Public Leadership and Management) 4th edition, 2016.

Austin, J. (Summer 2003). Strategic Alliances: Managing the collaboration portfolio. Stanford Social Innovation Review. Retrieved from: https://ssir.org/articles/entry/strategic_alliances

Thursday, March 9, 2017

Strategic planning helps organizations thrive


Organizations that want to thrive into the future - like the Seattle Youth Involvement Network (SIYN) - understand that only through the process of strategic planning can leadership effectively evaluate and address gaps or challenges.  After 10 years of serving the Seattle community, SIYN leaders determined there was a critical need to develop a responsive strategic plan due to:
  1. Instability and an identity crisis stemming from constant changes in scope and programming to meet the interest of staff, board members, and funders. 

2.     A confusing lack of organizational differentiation due to a changing community and rapidly growing number of organizations providing youth engagement services.

3.     Timeline-related need to revisit strategic development, as initial official strategic plan had limited four-year outlook.

At the outset, SIYN leaders ambitiously sought to give the organization a new vision, develop a framework for carrying out its mission, streamline programming, and improve fund raising and public relations” (Lovelady).
The first step was a situational analysis where board and staff came together to assess SYIN’s strengths, weaknesses, opportunities and threats, what is commonly called a “SWOT” analysis. This analysis is essential as it makes it possible to match an organization’s strengths with market opportunities (Assignment).

Market research, then, is the second crucial element in the strategic planning process. Given SIYN’s concerns about changes in the community and increased competition, their research included a review of demographic information, research on best practices and a colleague-competitor scan.  The scan supported SYIN’s assumption that they were working in a very competitive market, a key threat.  However, the research also affirmed that SYIN was a good collaborator and had deep relationships with collegial organizations, an organizational strength.

Importantly, the combination of these two elements -  SWOTS analysis and external market data - serve to provide critical data to support strategy development. Without this information and insight, the organization’s strategies will not be in alignment with or effective in the marketplace (Assignment).  Stakeholder input, which is typically gathered through surveys, focus groups, and interviews, is also viewed as a critical initial step in strategy development.    

In formulating the strategic plan, results of the entire SIYN planning process were compiled and presented to board members, staff and volunteers in preparation for a strategic planning retreat. Retreat participants, working in small groups, used the compiled data “to discuss questions around the role of the organization, its primary purpose, and what region and population it should serve” (Lovelady).
The results of those discussions lead to a new mission to address what the organization deemed to be the largest gap in youth service: political involvement and expanded programming statewide. It read: “We educate, empower, and engage Washington youth in the democratic process to encourage youth voice and promoted a lifetime of participation in their communities” (Lovelady). The previous mission was much broader in purporting to strive for a society that respects youth leaders, develop an effective and confident youth voice, and create avenues for civic involvement, leadership training, and decision-making.

The planning group also identified five goals relating to volunteer engagement, partnerships with investors, brand recognition and public relations, quality programming, and staff capacity.  Either directly or indirectly, each of these goals relate back to weaknesses identified by the SWOT analysis.

With a new identity as 2V/ACT, the organization sought to implement the plan. However, the ambitious statewide effort was challenged by both insufficient funding and board and staff capacity, forcing further consideration of options about the future of the organization.  Whatever the decision now though, the executive director continued to focus on the process as most important – it needed to be intentional, transparent, and true to 2V/ACT’s mission. 

References

Lovelady, Beth. “2V/ACT: Planning for Change and Determining Relevance.” The Electronic Hallway, University of Washington: Seattle, WA.
Assignment Point website. “When should a strategic plan be developed,” 2017. http://www.assignmentpoint.com/business/strategic-management-business/when-should-a-strategic-plan-be-developed.html

Strategic Planning-The Guide to Achieving Dreams

If you are someone who is familiar with the business or nonprofit world, it is more than likely that you have heard the term “strategic planning”. The phrase gets thrown around quite often, and for good reason too. If done properly strategic planning can offer an organization many benefits, including increased efficiency, innovation, adaptability and longevity. While it may sound simple enough, in reality strategic planning can easily be done incorrectly. Fortunately, if you follow the critical steps for successful strategic planning outlined below, you and your organization will be well on your way to accomplishing its goals!

Planning Hope

In my experience at various nonprofits, strategic planning has been an elusive concept, a “buzz word” organizations threw around without much action. Recently, I had the opportunity to participate in the strategic planning process at Madison Nonprofit*. Madison Nonprofit’s approach to strategic planning included many of the crucial elements, but they have work to do in executing the full cycle of strategic planning.

1. Review Mission

The 9-month strategic planning process at Madison Nonprofit began with a review of the organization’s mission, a crucial first step (Brown). The mission is an organization’s reason for existence and serves as a constant reference point throughout every stage of strategic planning and all subsequent decision making (United Way; Brown). Though Madison Nonprofit opted not to alter its existing mission, the mission did continue to serve as a cornerstone to each additional step in the process.

2. Situational Assessment

Additionally, Madison Nonprofit began its strategic planning with several approaches to assess the organizational, or internal, environment, as well as the external environment. For instance, Madison Nonprofit included staff of all levels and stakeholders, engaging them in an organizational retreat, interviews and focus groups, and program mapping activities to identify organizational strengths and weaknesses, as well as community needs and external trends.

Considering both the external and internal environment is a crucial step in strategic planning (Brown). Often, organizations jump to considering the external environment without considering the internal state of the organization. However, internal human, financial, technological, and structural capacity are key components to organization effectiveness and impact (United Way). These internal conditions should be assessed in addition to the external environment’s social, economic, and political states or trends (United Way). In engaging external and internal stakeholders, Madison Nonprofit set itself up well to analyze internally and externally. Additionally, it maintained a balanced view and approached identifying any organizational weaknesses or external threats as an opportunity to explore how to build strengths and improve performance (Bryson).

3. Identify Strategic Issues & 4. Formulate Strategies

Using information garnered from the situational assessments, Madison Nonprofit identified critical questions and challenges affecting the organization’s mission, service and stakeholders; these are defined as strategic issues (Bryson). Identifying strategic issues helps encourage an organization to think differently “so that knowledge exploration, development, and learning might occur” (Bryson, 252). Madison Nonprofit identified four strategic issues -- family and community engagement, building a sustainable business model, equity and inclusion, staff development and retention – and then created sub-committees to learn more and identify strategic issues within each area. To address strategic issues, each sub-committee created strategies and tasks to address each strategic issue. These were compiled into a “Strategic Plan” which was approved and adopted by the Board.

5. Create Implementation Plan & 6.  Evaluation

Madison Nonprofit effectively performed each of the above steps, but then mistakenly viewed the strategic process as complete. Each key strategic issue had several sub-goals, and many sub-tasks for each goal. Yet, Madison Nonprofit did not prioritize the many tasks (such as by assessing an issue’s probability and impact), create a plan for implementation, nor include a plan to evaluate, crucial steps to strategic planning (United Way; Bryson). Evaluation is critical and informs each step of the strategic planning process, from helping the organization identify strengths and weaknesses to monitoring progress, outputs, and outcomes (Bryson).


Benefits of Strategic Planning

By engaging in strategic planning, Madison Nonprofit gained some benefits of strategic planning including integrating perspectives from multiple stakeholders and creating goals to help the organization move forward (Brown). Additionally, strategic planning helped align the organization, providing an opportunity to discuss its purpose and helping to set its future course (Bryson). Overall, strategic planning helps an organization be more proactive and forward-thinking. To fully realize these benefits, Madison Nonprofit must keep strategic thinking on the forefront of its mind and continue to review and re-evaluate the three-year plan it created. Creating more clear plans for implementation and evaluation will complete the work they have done so far and foster strategic planning’s ability to “make hope reasonable” (Bryson).


*name has been changed to preserve the anonymity of the organization

 References:
Brown, William M. The Jossey-Bass handbook of nonprofit leadership and management. Ch 8: Strategic Management. John Wiley & Sons, 2016.

Bryson, John. The Jossey-Bass handbook of nonprofit leadership and management. Ch 9: Strategic Planning and the Strategy Change Cycle. John Wiley & Sons, 2016.

United Way of Dane County. Strategic Planning Process.

Thursday, February 16, 2017

Staying Competitive: The Do's of a Strategic Makeover



The challenge to remain competitive today is forcing businesses and organizations, including those in the nonprofit sector, to reconsider the basic concept of strategy.

Monday, May 4, 2015

Diversity, Inclusion, and Leadership

The United States is known as a melting pot of races, ethnicities, religions, cultures, and traditions, and has always prided itself on that description. We have only grown more diverse as a nation over time; moreover, new media has allowed for a significant increase in racial/ethnic group identity and pride, not to mention an easy and effective way to share information and organize for change (Shivers 2004).

Friday, May 1, 2015

Proactive Diversity

The recent tragic deaths of unarmed black men, including Michael Brown, Eric Garner and Freddie Gray, are calling into question our commitment to diversity as a nation. We should be challenged to authentically consider the extent to which our country, our states and our cities are not only diverse, but inclusive.

No more excuses: The pressing need for meaningful police reform


Thursday, April 30, 2015

A Call for Diversity

Recent tragic events across the country have raised awareness of the use of violence in the police force. Most recently in Baltimore - and from Ferguson to Madison - local police forces have been debated and defended, accused and inspected - locally, in national news outlets, and around the world.

What are "these" people so mad about? The answers aren't so complicated.

I want to tell you a personal story.
I went to a private K-8 school. Each year, I had a summer reading list, curated by my teacher. We built ships around our desks in fifth grade to study colonial times, and ended the year with a trip to Jamestown and Williamsburg. We put on musical plays, created dossiers in French class, and learned African drumming in "Movement." And then, my parents--who have always been committed to their community-- happily sent my siblings and me to public high school. They believed in all forms of education, and they knew I would be a more well-rounded person if I had a breath of experience. 

How Can We Make 1+1=3?

In November, the unarmed African American teenager Michael Brown died after being shot by a white officer in Ferguson, and in March, Tony Robinson died after being shot by an officer here in Madison (Buchanan et al., 2014). Until eight months ago, I lived in Sweden, where the increase from one to six deadly officer involved shootings yearly has been challenged. (Hårdh & Stauffer, 2015) I do think that the average U.S. police officer faces a larger number of challenging and stressful situations than the average Swedish one does. Nevertheless, I believe we have a problem when unarmed individuals loose their lives. Furthermore, the response reminds us that structural racism exists and makes me question if this is really the land of opportunity for all. With that said, the focus of this blog is not to provide a description of the problem – but instead to give good arguments for diversity and discuss how you and I, as leaders and individuals, can promote it.

Statistics tell us that hundreds of police departments are not representative of the communities in which they serve - the percentage of whites in the police force is many times more than 30 percentage points higher than in the community. These findings go against convincing evidence that a more representative police force will be more credible and build more trust in the communities in which they serve. (Ashkenas & Park, 2015) Furthermore, we know that, in general, more diverse organizations perform best and make better decisions. However, as pointed out by Page (2007) and Thomas and Ely (1996), if we want to build more productive organization we have to go beyond thinking about diversity as identity-group representation – think instead about the “varied perspectives and approaches to work that different identity groups bring”. Page (2007) gives evidence that a diverse group of individuals can outperform groups with “high ability” individuals because diverse perspectives and heuristics result in superadditivity (1+1=3). This economic logic of diversity is also supported by Robinson and Dechant (2007).

So, what should leaders do? I believe each and every one of us can do a lot – and that we have a responsibility to do so. We can question our own assumptions. We can promote conversation. We can ask ourselves as well as others “Why?”. Implicit biases suggest that we might not only be unwilling to admit attitudes and beliefs, but we might also unknowingly hide something from ourselves as well as others. (Project Implicit, 2011)  A recent report by the Sentencing Project (2014) shows how these biases makes “white Americans overestimate the proportion of crime committed by people of color, and associate people of color with criminality” – up to 20-30 percent for certain crimes.

In light of these findings, we sometimes have to listen to things we might not want to hear. When you hear someone argue that people of color are overrepresented in the criminal statistics – ask why they think that is. As Charles M. Blow points out in his column in The New York Times, it is true that crime rates are higher in minority neighborhoods – but why is that? Is there a correlation between race and concentrated poverty? Do poorer schools and limited job opportunities impact if you manage to leave a high-poverty, high-crime neighborhood? (Blow, 2014)  

Furthermore, we can ask ourselves what we base our perception of the world on. I would like to end by showing this satiric clip illustrating how biased media can be in covering crime involving people of color. It reminds me that we should aim to ensure that tolerance, strong values and solutions survive, grow stronger and finally win – creating a world where there is only us.

References

Ashkenas, Jeremy & Park, Haeyoun. 2015. The Race Gap in America’s Police Departments, The New York Times. Retrieved from: http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2014/09/03/us/the-race-gap-in-americas-police-departments.html?_r=0
Buchanan, L et al.. 2014. What Happened in Ferguson? The New York Times. Retrieved from: http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2014/08/13/us/ferguson-missouri-town-under-siege-after-police-shooting.html
Blow, Charles M. 2014. Crime and Punishment. The New York Times. http://www.nytimes.com/2014/12/01/opinion/charles-blow-crime-and-punishment.html
Ghandnoosh, Nazgol. 2014. Race and Punishment: Racial Perceptions of Crime and Support for Punitive Policies. The Sentence Project. Retrieved from: http://www.sentencingproject.org/doc/publications/rd_Race_and_Punishment.pdf
Hårdh, Robert & Stauffer, John. 2015. Debattreplik om polisens dödsskjutningar. Civil Rights Defenders. Retrieved from: http://www.civilrightsdefenders.org/sv/news/svenska-debattreplik-om-polisens-dodsskjutningar/
Page, Scott E. 2007. Making the Difference: Applying a Logic of Diversity, Academy of Management, vol. 21 no. 4
Project Implicit. 2011. Education.  https://implicit.harvard.edu/implicit/copyright.html
 Robinson, Gail and Kathleen Dechant. 2004. Building a Business Case for Diversity. Understanding and Managing Diversity: Readings, Cases, and Exercises 3rd ed. Pearson Prentice Hall. p. 241-253.
 Thomas, David A. & Ely, Robin J. 2004. “Making Differences Matter: A New Paradigm for Managing Diversity.” Understanding and Managing Diversity: Readings, Cases, and Exercises 3rd ed. Pearson Prentice Hall. p. 211-227.


Reactions to Oppression

Let me begin by saying that much like Deray McKesson who recently spoke with Wolf Blitzer on CNN (http://www.rawstory.com/2015/04/activist-smacks-down-wolf-blitzer-you-are-suggesting-broken-windows-are-worse-than-broken-spines/) I support peaceful protesting, and having trained police officers in crisis intervention I have great respect for law enforcement and the risks they take and also know that there are dedicated, kind, caring, and compassionate people who serve on the police force. At the same time, much like McKesson I refuse to criticize those who have rioted over the police brutality that has resulted in the death of Freddie Gray. The predominant focus of the media over the last few days on destruction of property in regard to the Baltimore riots, and the predominant response of white people in concern over riots that have resulted in property damage (http://www.dailykos.com/story/2015/04/28/1380944/-The-Dominant-White-Response-to-Baltimore-Shows-Why-Black-Residents-are-Justified-in-their-Anger) to be quite frank is unacceptable. Comparisons between movements can be problematic, and I don’t want to draw direct comparisons, rather I want to highlight two other movements here to express why I personally cannot condemn these riots and to hopefully illustrate why focusing on condemnation of riots versus condemnation of the despicable inequities which caused those riots is hypocritical.

Reflecting on the movement of my own marginalized community, the queer community, those of us who identify across the LGBTQ spectrum cannot so easily condemn rioting when riots are exactly what started our modern movement for civil rights equality at Stonewall in 1969 (http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/americanexperience/features/introduction/stonewall-intro/). We retaliated against police raids and arrests that were destroying our communities and our lives in that moment and began a movement for our rights and for change which I as an openly gay man in my mid 20s have reaped the benefits of and am thankful for. I should also note that our community rose up in riot when the killer of Harvey Milk was convicted of only manslaughter rather than murder in 1979, receiving a sentence of 7 years (which wound up only being 4) rather than a harsher sentence (http://thecastro.net/milk/whitenight.html). Given these events and the impact they had I cannot condemn the rioting that is currently happening because it would be hypocritical to say that my community was allowed to riot against injustice enforced and enacted by the police but communities of color are not permitted to do the same.

While this example of rioting as rejection of oppression is one that feels more salient to me there is another that is applicable to a much larger proportion of the American populous. I think we forget the history of our nation in these moments and that the United States itself was born out of retaliation against oppression. The Boston Massacre of 1770 where 5 men were killed by British soldiers, the passage of the Tea Act of 1773 which symbolized the concept of “taxation without representation” and led to the Boston Tea Party, and other oppressive acts of the British government led to fighting with British soldiers, the declaring of independence in 1776, and fighting a war to escape an oppressive regime (http://www.history.com/topics/american-revolution/american-revolution-history). The colonization of the Americas was an oppressive act in and of itself and, again, it is not my intent to make direct comparisons here between movements or between British soldiers and modern police; however, I think it’s important to realize that when people are oppressed they react.


Black Americans experience economic inequity, educational inequity, and disproportionate rates of incarceration (http://www.nytimes.com/2014/08/20/upshot/americas-racial-divide-charted.html?_r=0&abt=0002&abg=1; http://www.naacp.org/pages/criminal-justice-fact-sheet) just to name a few systemic injustices. I am not saying rioting will inevitably right those injustices, but I am saying what needs to be criticized here are the oppressions, the inequities, the injustices, not the breaking of windows.