The recent tragic deaths of unarmed black men, including Michael Brown, Eric Garner and Freddie Gray, are calling into question our commitment to diversity as a nation. We should be challenged to authentically consider the extent to which our country, our states and our cities are not only diverse, but inclusive.
Showing posts with label Wild. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Wild. Show all posts
Friday, May 1, 2015
Thursday, April 9, 2015
Collaboration: What to know before joining forces
Collaboration seems simple enough: two organizations work together to reach a common goal. In practice, the process requires thoughtful, strategic planning and action. Collaboration across sectors introduces the potential for unique challenges and opportunities. Below I'll address three cases of collaboration between organizations and lessons to draw from each.
1. The Seattle Art Museum (SAM) and First Things First (FTF)
FTF, which advocated for affordable housing, and SAM were both Seattle-based nonprofits. These seemingly unrelated organizations began collaborating when they both hoped to receive funding from the local government. Both organizations were to be listed on the ballot of a September 16 tax levy referendum. The two organizations realized that by working against the other, they were both likely to fail. FTF had a strong, active volunteer base. SAM had political connections and funds available to promote the vote. The nonprofits decided to form a coalition and advocate for funding for both organizations. They were working for a common goal: creating a better seattle. This collaboration was beneficial for both nonprofits. The United Way Best Practices Summary identifies a number of benefits of collaboration, including:
-"Conserve resources by avoiding unnecessary duplication of services
-Share similar concerns while being enriched by diverse perspectives that different members from varied backgrounds bring to the collaboration" (United Way Worldwide).
The SAM and FTF coalition encompasses both of these benefits. Rather than enlisting volunteers to advocate on behalf of SAM and different volunteers to advocate on behalf of FTF, the organizations were able to combine their resources to form a single team of volunteers. Further, the different kinds of expertise that members of the two organizations brought to the coalition contributed knowledge of the political climate, voter interests and turnout, among other important factors.
2. Massachusetts Department of Social Services (MDSS) and La Alianza Hispana (LAH)
This case provides insight into the choices that organizations must make before collaborating. MDSS, a government agency, invited LAH, a nonprofit, to collaborate to provide culturally sensitive service in the area of child protection. This decision would provide LAH with additional funding from MDSS and offered an opportunity for the nonprofit to expand. LAH served as a supportive resource for the Latino community. Collaboration would put them in the position of a regulatory body. In her article on collaboration, Janet Sharma identifies factors that contribute to the success of a collaboration. One of these is a shared vision. Although MDSS and LAH both worked to promote the wellbeing of children in the community, they operated in a very different way. LAH's vision meant serving the community in a supportive role, while MDSS served in an actively regulatory, supervisory role.
3. City Year and Timberland
For a time, the nonprofit, City Year, and the for-profit business, Timberland, formed a collaboration. The organizations worked together to advocate for social justice. Timberland was able to advertise their partnership with City Year to present themselves as an ethical company seeking to have a positive impact on the community. City Year benefited from financial support as well as donations of staff uniforms. The United Way Best Practices article identifies a key to successful collaboration as requiring the participation of individuals who have a stake in the collaboration. "They must agree that the process of collaborating is as valuable as the results" (United Way Worldwide). While the organizations had a shared vision, the details of the process of collaboration was not as clear. When Timberland encountered financial challenges, the business's commitment to City Year was challenged and many stakeholders did not the support the collaboration. In this instance, all relevant members were not made a part of the collaboration process and this affected the collaboration negatively.
Lessons to draw from these cases include that collaboration is not always a good idea, organizations in a collaboration should have a shared vision, ensure that relevant stakeholders are involved in the process and that when organizations collaborate well, they can do more together than they could separately.
Resources:
Fortier, S. 1996. Funding Seattle’s Art Museum and Low-Income Housing: The Politics of Interest Groups and Tax Levies (A). Supervisor Jon Brock. Cascade Center for Public Service: Public Service Curriculum Exchange.
Sharma, Janet and Amanda Missey. 1998. “How I learned to Stop Griping . . . And Love Collaboration.” From a presentation at the National Community Service Conference. June 30, 1998. New Orleans, LA.
United Way Worldwide. "Best Practices Summary: Collaboration, Coalition-Building and Merger." 2008.
Varley, Pamela. “Partners in Child Protection Services: The Department of Social Services and La Alianza Hispana.” Boston. Harvard Kennedy School, 1996.
1. The Seattle Art Museum (SAM) and First Things First (FTF)
FTF, which advocated for affordable housing, and SAM were both Seattle-based nonprofits. These seemingly unrelated organizations began collaborating when they both hoped to receive funding from the local government. Both organizations were to be listed on the ballot of a September 16 tax levy referendum. The two organizations realized that by working against the other, they were both likely to fail. FTF had a strong, active volunteer base. SAM had political connections and funds available to promote the vote. The nonprofits decided to form a coalition and advocate for funding for both organizations. They were working for a common goal: creating a better seattle. This collaboration was beneficial for both nonprofits. The United Way Best Practices Summary identifies a number of benefits of collaboration, including:
-"Conserve resources by avoiding unnecessary duplication of services
-Share similar concerns while being enriched by diverse perspectives that different members from varied backgrounds bring to the collaboration" (United Way Worldwide).
The SAM and FTF coalition encompasses both of these benefits. Rather than enlisting volunteers to advocate on behalf of SAM and different volunteers to advocate on behalf of FTF, the organizations were able to combine their resources to form a single team of volunteers. Further, the different kinds of expertise that members of the two organizations brought to the coalition contributed knowledge of the political climate, voter interests and turnout, among other important factors.
2. Massachusetts Department of Social Services (MDSS) and La Alianza Hispana (LAH)
This case provides insight into the choices that organizations must make before collaborating. MDSS, a government agency, invited LAH, a nonprofit, to collaborate to provide culturally sensitive service in the area of child protection. This decision would provide LAH with additional funding from MDSS and offered an opportunity for the nonprofit to expand. LAH served as a supportive resource for the Latino community. Collaboration would put them in the position of a regulatory body. In her article on collaboration, Janet Sharma identifies factors that contribute to the success of a collaboration. One of these is a shared vision. Although MDSS and LAH both worked to promote the wellbeing of children in the community, they operated in a very different way. LAH's vision meant serving the community in a supportive role, while MDSS served in an actively regulatory, supervisory role.
3. City Year and Timberland
For a time, the nonprofit, City Year, and the for-profit business, Timberland, formed a collaboration. The organizations worked together to advocate for social justice. Timberland was able to advertise their partnership with City Year to present themselves as an ethical company seeking to have a positive impact on the community. City Year benefited from financial support as well as donations of staff uniforms. The United Way Best Practices article identifies a key to successful collaboration as requiring the participation of individuals who have a stake in the collaboration. "They must agree that the process of collaborating is as valuable as the results" (United Way Worldwide). While the organizations had a shared vision, the details of the process of collaboration was not as clear. When Timberland encountered financial challenges, the business's commitment to City Year was challenged and many stakeholders did not the support the collaboration. In this instance, all relevant members were not made a part of the collaboration process and this affected the collaboration negatively.
Lessons to draw from these cases include that collaboration is not always a good idea, organizations in a collaboration should have a shared vision, ensure that relevant stakeholders are involved in the process and that when organizations collaborate well, they can do more together than they could separately.
Resources:
Fortier, S. 1996. Funding Seattle’s Art Museum and Low-Income Housing: The Politics of Interest Groups and Tax Levies (A). Supervisor Jon Brock. Cascade Center for Public Service: Public Service Curriculum Exchange.
Sharma, Janet and Amanda Missey. 1998. “How I learned to Stop Griping . . . And Love Collaboration.” From a presentation at the National Community Service Conference. June 30, 1998. New Orleans, LA.
United Way Worldwide. "Best Practices Summary: Collaboration, Coalition-Building and Merger." 2008.
Varley, Pamela. “Partners in Child Protection Services: The Department of Social Services and La Alianza Hispana.” Boston. Harvard Kennedy School, 1996.
Thursday, March 12, 2015
Strategic Planning: Don't Let Good Intentions Go To Waste
While improvising an organizational plan as you go along may seem an attractive and time-saving option, it ultimately will prevent an organization from reaching its full potential. Organizational leaders may feel that the organization's expertise and good intentions will allow them to navigate challenges as they arise. While employee & volunteer expertise and good intentions are invaluable assets to an organization, this is not the best way to put these abilities to use. To the contrary, it is the role of leaders to tap into the expertise and good intentions that exist within an organization and channel those into the organization's strategic development. Strategic management scholar, John M. Bryson, writes: "Think of strategic planning as organizing hope, as what makes hope reasonable" (Bryson 2010). Even the best of intentions can get lost if the organization is not operating strategically and intentionally. The strategic planning process is undoubtedly unique to each organization, but a few key steps should play a role.
1. Revisit the Mission
Put candidly, if you don't know what you're trying to do, you're probably not doing it. Make sure the mission reflects the organization's values and clarifies the organization's reason for existence. The mission should serve as a reference point for employees and stakeholders (United Way of Dane County).
2. Articulate a Vision
Similarly, if you don't know where you're going, you're probably not going to get there. An organization's vision should dictate what kind of future the organization seeks to create. The vision should help employees & volunteers understand the direction of the organization's work in the short or long term (United Way of Dane County).
3. SWOT Analysis
The Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities and Threats Analysis encourages organizations to look at their internal and external environments and move forward with a strategy that capitalizes on and addresses these categories, respectively. Looking at strengths and weaknesses requires reflecting on internal aspects while opportunities and threats are external and should be considered in a strategic planning process accordingly (Bryson 2010).
4. Define a Strategic Issue
The identification of a strategic issue facing the organization is a helpful part of the strategic planning process. The United Way of Dane County identifies characteristics of a strategic issue: "An internal or external development that could impact the organization's performance to which the organization must respond in an orderly fashion and over which the organization may reasonably expect to exert some influence" (United Way of Dane County). The process of addressing strategic strategic issues should include significant dialogue with and expertise from stakeholders.
5. Make the Plan a Reality
An intentional and well-developed implementation process provides the link between strategic planning to strategic action. The process should include a schedule for planned future actions/changes, designate roles and responsibilities, list specific action steps to take, detail resources required and establish a communication process (Bryson 2010).
After your strategic plan is successfully developed and implemented, it is critical to revisit the plan to reassess strategy and make changes as necessary. Certainly, strategic planning is not always such a clear process, but this framework will put your organization in the best place for a successful strategic planning process.
References:
1.United Way of Dane County. Strategic Planning Process.
2. Bryson, John M. 2010. Strategic Planning and the Strategy Planning Circle. In: Renz, David O. The Jossey-Bass Handbook of Nonprofit Leadership and Management. Jossey-Bass. San Francisco, CA.
Wednesday, February 18, 2015
Out with the Old, In with the New: Change in Organizations
Successful organizations embrace change and encourage innovation. With this in mind, it's surprising that organizational cultures often discourage the actions that lead to such change and innovation. Frankly, change is uncomfortable and innovation requires taking risks. If an organization doesn't actively create an environment in which change and innovation can thrive, it simply won't happen.
Sources:
1. Cameron, Kim. 1991. "Transformational Leadership." In Developing Management Skills. David A. Whetton and Kim S.
Cameron. New York: Harper Collins.2. Charan, Ram and Noel Tichy. 1989. "Speed, Simplicity, Self-Confidence: An Interview with Jack Welch." Harvard Business Review. No. 89513:110-120
3. "The List: CNBC First 25 Rebels, Icons and Leaders." CNBC.
Five Ways to Encourage Change in Your Organization:
1. Listen
Strategies for change should not be created behind closed doors or in isolation. Strategic change should be done with market trends in mind and taking into account the perspectives of employees at all levels of the organization. Jack Welch was the CEO of General Electric from 1981 to 2001. During his time in this role, GE's market capitalization rose from $14 billion to more than $400 billion ("The List: CNBC First 25 Rebels, Icons and Leaders"). Of his leadership strategy, he says "Above all else, though, good leaders are open. They go up, down, and around their organization to reach people. They don't stick to the established channels...They make a religion out of being accessible"(Charan). Change is most effective and successful when it is created in consideration of the best interest of the organization as a whole.
2. Empower Employees
If employees are weighed down by micromanagement and adherence to procedure, there is little room for innovation and improvement. Empowered employees are encouraged to develop improved processes and find ways that the organization can do better. Welch increased beyond the industry average the number of employees that each manager is responsible for leading. He says, "With 10 or 15 reports, a leader can focus only on the big important issues, not on minutiae" (Charan). This arrangement empowers both employees and managers to focus on the big picture and make positive change when needed.
3. Encourage Risk-Taking
Some of the most important changes in an organization are made in uncharted territory. They are risks, and the possibility of failure is real. However, to move beyond mediocrity and into a truly innovative organization, taking risks is necessary. Encourage employees to try new things and don't disregard an idea because it's different from the way things have always been done. Management and Organizations scholar, Kim Cameron, encourages organizations to adopt a philosophy in which, "Improvement is the standard to be rewarded, not just doing the job correctly" (Cameron).
4. Implement "Change-Friendly" Management
Even the best ideas for change can get lost in a bureaucratic environment. Employees' ideas for change may never reach the organization's leadership. Leadership's ideas for change may be misconstrued or watered down by the time they are relayed to lower-level employees. Cameron recommends creating a flatter management structure which will foster accessibility and a more rapid response time to new ideas (Cameron).
5. Articulate a Vision
Having a clear vision is helpful for encouraging innovation or implementing a new initiative. Forming this vision should involve creating a strategic plan with input from a range of organizational voices. After this vision is created, leadership should generate commitment and seek to institutionalize the principles set forth by the new initiative (Cameron).
1. Cameron, Kim. 1991. "Transformational Leadership." In Developing Management Skills. David A. Whetton and Kim S.
Cameron. New York: Harper Collins.2. Charan, Ram and Noel Tichy. 1989. "Speed, Simplicity, Self-Confidence: An Interview with Jack Welch." Harvard Business Review. No. 89513:110-120
3. "The List: CNBC First 25 Rebels, Icons and Leaders." CNBC.
Thursday, January 29, 2015
4 Things You Need to Know about the Nonprofit Sector
Philanthropy is commendable,
but it must not cause the philanthropist to overlook the circumstances of
economic injustice which make philanthropy necessary.
Martin Luther King, Jr.
Nonprofit organizations today operate in an increasingly
complex and interconnected environment. In order to understand the role of
nonprofit organizations today, it is helpful to look at the nonprofit sector as
it relates to the public sector (government) and the private sector (business).
1. Nonprofits step in where Government and Business
left off
Government offers basic services to
address social needs such as the Food Share program, subsidized healthcare and
public transportation. However, in a political climate of demands for tax cuts
and a smaller government, the role of government in addressing social needs is
shrinking. In his article, “Doing ‘Good’ vs. Doing ‘Well’: The Role of
Nonprofits in Society”, Berman notes that although the role of government may
decrease, the needs of society do not decrease correspondingly (Berman, 2002).
Businesses vary greatly in their
social impact, but businesses simply cannot exist in the long run if they don’t
make a profit. Making a positive societal impact must take the back seat to
profit in a business. Social welfare
cannot be realized by the public nor private sector in these circumstances. There
is a real and pressing need for nonprofit work.
2. Nonprofits Make a Profit
Nonprofit organizations are not legally
prevented from making a profit. The key difference is what they are legally
permitted to do with that profit. Nonprofit organizations, unlike government
and business, are subject to the doctrine of private inurement. Basically, this
ensures nonprofits are operated for the benefit of those they serve, by
preventing nonprofits from passing their profits on to employees and the board.
This makes nonprofits unique. Successful
businesses make a profit and pass it on those with an interest in the business
such as shareholders/owners and employees (though not usually in equal
proportion). Moreover, we’ve surely all heard by now condemnation of the
government deficit. The government ought to make a profit, too, though it is
not always distributed in the same manner as in businesses (Renz, 2010).
3. Businesses have stockholders, Nonprofits have stakeholders
Businesses are ultimately accountable to their owners. The government is (supposed to be) ultimately accountable to its citizens. The nonprofit accountability arrangement varies greatly. Nonprofits based on membership (such as the American Association of University Women or the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People) are accountable to their members. Organizations that provide a service are accountable to those they serve, although this may be ineffective. Policy advocacy networks such as the Sierra Club and Amnesty International have some accountability to their members, who pay dues, and their volunteers. Other nonprofits seem to only be accountable to whichever members of society they claim as their stakeholders. The relationship is much less defined (Renz, 2010).
4. There’s no such thing as “one size
fits all” in the Nonprofit Sector
There is an incredible amount of nonprofit organizations today. These include charitable, educational, religious, scientific, social and political organizations, among many others. (Did you know the NFL is a nonprofit?) Moreover, there are many nonprofits that resemble businesses (such as microfinance organizations, like KIVA) and nonprofits that maintain a close relationship with government. Keep in mind, when considering the nonprofit sector, that nonprofit interests, goals and activities constitute a very wide range (Renz, 2010).
References:
Berman, Howard J. 2002. Doing "Good" vs. Doing "Well": The Role of Nonprofits in Society. Inquiry 39: 5-11.
Renz, David O, ed. 2010. The Jossey-Bass Handbook of Nonprofit Leadership and Management. Jossey-Bass. San Francisco, CA.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)