Showing posts with label Nonprofit Organizations. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Nonprofit Organizations. Show all posts

Wednesday, April 29, 2015

Cultures Are Not Bumper Stickers*: Valuing Diversity and Subverting Discrimination

America has a history of cultural diversity and tension around it. Our cultures are integral to our individual and group identities – usually drawn upon identity-group lines like race, ethnicity, religion, sex, or sexual orientation. Past rhetoric refers with pride to America’s “melting pot” of cultural heritage, but today you are more likely to hear the word “implicit bias” and “disproportionate incarceration” when referring to America’s contemporary diversity policies. Officer shootings of black men have turned public attention to structural racism and how we can direct our own efforts to addressing the need for more authentic action on diversity issues.

Why should you care? Ethics and economics. Many of us react emotionally, even viscerally to these issues. As far back as the U.S. Declaration of Independence we have held the belief that everyone deserves the right to “life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness” and in the twentieth century many cultures around the world internalized the idea of dignity as a human right (McNett 2004). That queasy, uncomfortable feeling is our internalized values telling us discrimination is ethically wrong. But beyond ethics, simple economic logic also supports the idea that society is most productive as a whole when a diverse group is allowed to question the process and drive innovation (Robinson and Dechant 2004). We care because it’s our ethical and societal responsibility to do so and we stand to gain from acting on it. 

What needs to be done? We need to move away from the models that we have used to address diversity issues and shift paradigms to truly value different cultural and individual perspectives. Common models of encouraging diversity in the past have been affirmative action-type and legacy legitimacy-type. The first employs quotas to make groups look more like society and comply with federal programs. Women and people of color are implicitly expected to blend in to the historical organizational culture. Legacy legitimacy programs seek diversity because it’s good business; they assign diverse staff to responsibilities associated with their background to gain market insight into that identity-group. Both of these approaches perpetuate discrimination. The diversity of opinions and life learning that staff members bring to the table are not independently valued; and they are discouraged from challenging how work is done (Thomas and Ely 2004). Men and women who enter companies under such diversity programs are often assigned to unchallenging positions with little opportunity for advancement (Robinson and Dechant 2004). Both styles of diversity management fail to harness the potential of a diverse workforce and perpetuate structural disadvantages.

But what can I do? Be a leader. Recognize and value differences from cultural diversity. Brainstorm ways to foster an organizational culture that makes everyone feel valued and is open to new ideas and change. Start open discussions about how workers' identity-group membership influences their experience in the organization. Above all, work to identify forms of dominance and insubordination which are often not readily visible and actively reform to avoid replicating those structures (Thomas and Ely 2004).

While the debate about structural racism in law enforcement has been the recent focus of public attention, structural discrimination runs through almost all facets of our society. Looking at law enforcement’s role in structural discrimination alone ignores the larger systemic problem and may once again create solutions like those described above where the problem is addressed where it is most visible, but not at its roots. If every organization in America - including police forces - took responsibility for how they engage and include diverse groups in their work, we would be well on our way to a more inclusive and productive society.

*The title of this piece “Cultures are not bumper stickers” is a quote from Sowell 2004

References

McNett, Jeanne (2004) “Diversity in the Workplace: Ethics, Pragmatism, or Some of Both?” Understanding and Managing Diversity: Readings, Cases, and Exercises 3rd ed. Pearson Prentice Hall. p. 241-253.

Robinson, Gail and Kathleen Dechant (2004) “Building a Business Case for Diversity.” Understanding and Managing Diversity: Readings, Cases, and Exercises 3rd ed. Pearson Prentice Hall. p. 228-240.

Sowell, Thomas (2004) “A World View of Cultural Diversity.” Understanding and Managing Diversity: Readings, Cases, and Exercises 3rd ed. Pearson Prentice Hall. p. 27-38

Thomas, David A. & Robin J. Ely (2004) “Making Differences Matter: A New Paradigm for Managing Diversity.” Understanding and Managing Diversity: Readings, Cases, and Exercises 3rd ed. Pearson Prentice Hall. p. 211-227.

Thursday, February 19, 2015

Change in Organizations: Why is it So Hard?

Change isn't easy for most people. It involves risk, taking on the unknown and, often, addressing one's own shortcomings. Change in organizations is not easy either.  On a base level, studies of organizational behavior show that people tend to prefer the status quo, and that they also prefer to avoid losses versus trying to make gains (known as loss aversion).

The real challenges organizations face, however, can be pinpointed to more precise issues. Below are five such challenges and some ways to overcome those barriers to change.
  1. Your organization doesn't understand its needs. An organization's shortfalls may seem obvious on the surface, but getting to the root causes of organizational issues requires a thorough analysis. Strategic planning offers a way for organizations to delve into its strengths, weaknesses, opportunities, and threats. Literature on strategic planning abounds, but your organization can also hire a consultant to help walk you through the strategic planning process.
  2. Change could mean HR complications. Organizational change inherently involves staff; even if they are not directly impacted, nervousness about what change might bring (the unknown) is likely to influence employee morale. Organizations should include employees in their discussions of change; they may bring a perspective of the organization that managers have not thought of. Managers should also consider the impact changes might make on employee roles, salary, and benefits. 
  3. Your Board isn't...well, on board. The relationship an organization has with its Board of Directors is complex; these relationships vary greatly from organization or organization in terms of Board involvement, influence, etc. Including Board members in strategic planning is a good way to get a sense of the organization from a non-management perspective. At the same time, it is important to remember that at the end of the day, an organization's head manager can override Board decisions. 
  4. You don't know if the change is actually working. When instituting change, it is essential to put measurements in place to gauge the impact of those changes. After implementing a new fundraising policy, for example, an organization might measure the increase (if any) on funds raised after three, six, and twelve months into the new policy.
  5. Your resources are lacking. Organizations are all competing for a limited amount of resources. Working together with similar organizations to create a network for change is one way to share resources and decrease silos. Internally, strategic planning will help an organization find areas where spending can be cut or reallocated. 
This list of challenges and possible solutions is by no means exhaustive. It is important to remember that while anticipating barriers to change is essential, it is also necessary to try to predict what the outcomes of various organizational responses to those barriers might be. These predictions will help management choose which path to take in response to challenges. 

Sources:

Cameron, Kim. "Transformational Leadership." Developing Management Skills. New York: Harper Collins, 1991.
Gowdy, Heather. "Convergence:  How Five Trends Will Reshape the Social Sector." The Irving Foundation. Nov. 2009.
Kaplan, Robert and David Norton. "The Balanced Scorecard: Measures that Drive Performance." Harvard Business Review. Jan-Feb 1992. 71-79.
Tregoe, Benjamin and John Zimmerman. "The Challenges of Strategic Management." Top Management Strategy:  What it is and How to Make it Work. Simon & Schuester, NY. 1980. 99-114.

Tuesday, February 17, 2015

Is Your Organization Ready for Change?


Change is hard. I think most of us would agree that sudden disruptions to our routine make us uncomfortable, and require more than our normal workload to simply adapt to the new state of affairs. These changes throw us off; they make us question our own competence because of the loss of familiarity associated with the old routine (Moss Kanter). As a leader of an organization, you must grapple with aversion to change to improve systems and keep the organization current with external pressures. Change is made particularly difficult by cumbersome or inflexible management practices that are unable to move quickly and adapt to change (Charan and Tichy). For nonprofits, an added difficulty is that funders favor established, proven methods over exploration of uncharted waters (Gowdy et al), perversely, innovation may actually limit resources.

So, what can we do to make change easier, faster, and funded? The answers lie in the development of a strategic plan with strong core principals and regular reevaluations along with improved management practices such as eliminating unneeded managerial layers, employing self-confident managerial skills, and involving relevant stakeholders. These five measures will help prepare an organization for change and ease tensions during the process. How you ask? Let’s get into it.

  1.             Develop a strategic plan with strong core principals. Planning to outline goals and strategies for achieving those goals is the key to organizational success (Renz Ch. 9).  It also sets a baseline; leaders have a solid communal definition of the organization’s essence. Moving forward on major organizational changes will be easier if you have clear core concepts that you can keep common throughout changes that the organization undergoes (Cameron).
  2.       Regularly evaluate your strategic plan. Regular reconsideration of this strategic plan then helps to insure that the strategies are proper and effective at achieving goals within the current environment. Constantly thinking about external changes that may impact the efficacy of your strategy and the future beyond the current strategic plan helps organizations see changes coming and preempt them (Tregoe).  
  3.       Limit managerial levels to those that are truly required. When supervisors are closer to the action they are more accessible to employees to hear complaints and suggestions and are thus directly connected to feedback loops within the organization. Streamlined management can also respond more quickly to change because they are not bogged down by complex hierarchical procedures (Charan and Tichy).
  4.       Be a self-confident manager. According to Charan and Tichy, this is a manager who is self-assured enough to accept feedback – good and bad – and incorporate improvements to their management style graciously. They challenge processes to make sure that performance is efficient and effective and take ownership over creating the simplified hierarchical structure discussed in #3, though it may involve difficult decisions. This style of leadership creates a flexible, responsive structure, more able to adjust to the demands of change.
  5.       Involve stakeholders and reward their adaptability. While asking for an inclusive decision making process slows down organizational response time, the key to successful change is to secure the buy-in of stakeholders, including funders. If stakeholders can’t give input before a change, make sure that they are informed of it and are presented a solid, evidence-based case for why it was pursued. Internally, rewarding exemplary adaptability and adoption of the new policies among staff and providing them with training opportunities builds support for change (Cameron).

      Good organizational planning and adept management practices together form an agile organization in tune with prevailing winds that can create successful change despite our individual and organizational aversion to it.

References:
- Cameron, Kim. 1991. “Transformational Leadership.” In Developing Management Skills. David A. Whetton and Kim S. Cameron. New York: Harper Collins.
- Charan, Ram and Noel Tichy. 1989. “Speed, Simplicity, Self-Confidence: An Interview with Jack Welch.” Harvard Business Review. No. 89513:110-120.
- Gowdy, Heather, Alex Hildebrand, David La Piana, and Melissa Mendes Campos. 2009. Convergence: How Five Trends will Reshape the Social Sector. La Piana Consulting.
- Moss Kanter, Rosabeth. 2012. “Ten Reasons People Resist Change.” Harvard Business Review: Change Management. Web. Accessed February 16, 2015. https://hbr.org/2012/09/ten-reasons-people-resist-chang/
- Renz, David O, ed. 2010. The Jossey-Bass Handbook of Nonprofit Leadership and Management. Jossey-Bass. San Francisco, CA. 

- Tregoe, Benjamin. 1983. “The Challenges of Strategic Management.” In Top Management Strategy. Benjamin B. Tregoe and John W. Zimmerman. New York: Simon and Schuster. 

Thursday, January 29, 2015

Why the nonprofit sector is unique

Non-profits in America are unique in that they give voice and place to some of society's most extraordinary needs. Nonprofits complete the web of work that we as a collective do, by supporting special interests, providing relief and developing community. Did you know that nonprofits exist in Colorado whose sole purpose is to provide bear-proof trashcans to citizens?1 There is an organization called the "National Odd Shoe Exchange" that specializes in providing one shoe for those who have a particular need. 2 Or take the cat allies nonprofit near Franklin County Florida that only serves the well-being of cats and cat allies on St. George Island. 3 The sector is diverse indeed.

Over 1.5 million nonprofits exist in the United States 4 and they are very different from their public and private sector siblings. Oftentimes nonprofits are encouraged to work more like organizations in the private sector who benefit from: quantifiable results, fewer budget constraints and more centralized processes. Americans have an affinity for efficiency, and when we see it happening in one place we wonder why it can't happen everywhere. I should admit that after having worked for nonprofits for eight years I too fell in and out of this mind trap. "If only we could be better at x, y, z... if only we had more money or more agile members... why can't my boss just delegate these tasks so that there is one direct person responsible for every project!!?" Well, there are a host of reasons why, and listing all of them would overwhelm this week's blog post. Additionally, my classmates presented strong contributions on the overarching attributes of nonprofits, so instead I will aim to drill down on one specific to example to illustrate the unique nature of nonprofit organizations. 

Evaluation. It cannot be overlooked that measurement and evaluation is very different for nonprofit organizations than it is for private and public sector organizations. Timelines for change and work with human services make determining outcomes tricky business. The work that nonprofits do does not often lend itself well to neat and tidy forms of measurement (the public sector can relate to this challenge as well, though I would argue that adding the public as a vested stakeholder whose dollars are at hand might put the public sector in an even more difficult place than many nonprofits). How can you linearly track the progress of individuals when so many factors have been involved in their growth? Collaboration is a key component of non-profits and is essential for budgeting, so which organization had the most impact or which organization deserves the kudos for the outcome? In a world of numbers, will quotes, pictures and success stories have as much of an impact? These strategies frequently work for public and private sector organizations and do not transfer as easily to many nonprofits.

Its also true that answers to these questions vary by organization. Therefore, what can the nonprofit do that its stepbrothers and sisters cannot? The nonprofit can have a nimble approach to its challenges. It is not the public or private sector and it must operate differently. In other words, it gets to operate differently! Approaching the sector this way reminds us of the void it fills in our nation's infrastructure- thus divinely pairing with the public and private realms of life. 

Additional sources:Renz, David O, ed. 2010. The Jossey-Bass Handbook of Nonprofit Leadership and Management. Jossey-Bass. San Francisco, CA. 


4 Things You Need to Know about the Nonprofit Sector

Philanthropy is commendable, but it must not cause the philanthropist to overlook the circumstances of economic injustice which make philanthropy necessary.
Martin Luther King, Jr. 

Nonprofit organizations today operate in an increasingly complex and interconnected environment. In order to understand the role of nonprofit organizations today, it is helpful to look at the nonprofit sector as it relates to the public sector (government) and the private sector (business).

1. Nonprofits step in where Government and Business left off

Government offers basic services to address social needs such as the Food Share program, subsidized healthcare and public transportation. However, in a political climate of demands for tax cuts and a smaller government, the role of government in addressing social needs is shrinking. In his article, “Doing ‘Good’ vs. Doing ‘Well’: The Role of Nonprofits in Society”, Berman notes that although the role of government may decrease, the needs of society do not decrease correspondingly (Berman, 2002).

Businesses vary greatly in their social impact, but businesses simply cannot exist in the long run if they don’t make a profit. Making a positive societal impact must take the back seat to profit in a business.  Social welfare cannot be realized by the public nor private sector in these circumstances. There is a real and pressing need for nonprofit work. 

2. Nonprofits Make a Profit
Nonprofit organizations are not legally prevented from making a profit. The key difference is what they are legally permitted to do with that profit. Nonprofit organizations, unlike government and business, are subject to the doctrine of private inurement. Basically, this ensures nonprofits are operated for the benefit of those they serve, by preventing nonprofits from passing their profits on to employees and the board.

This makes nonprofits unique. Successful businesses make a profit and pass it on those with an interest in the business such as shareholders/owners and employees (though not usually in equal proportion). Moreover, we’ve surely all heard by now condemnation of the government deficit. The government ought to make a profit, too, though it is not always distributed in the same manner as in businesses (Renz, 2010).

3. Businesses have stockholders, Nonprofits have stakeholders
Businesses are ultimately accountable to their owners. The government is (supposed to be) ultimately accountable to its citizens. The nonprofit accountability arrangement varies greatly. Nonprofits based on membership (such as the American Association of University Women or the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People) are accountable to their members. Organizations that provide a service are accountable to those they serve, although this may be ineffective. Policy advocacy networks such as the Sierra Club and Amnesty International have some accountability to their members, who pay dues, and their volunteers. Other nonprofits seem to only be accountable to whichever members of society they claim as their stakeholders. The relationship is much less defined (Renz, 2010).

4. There’s no such thing as “one size fits all” in the Nonprofit Sector 
There is an incredible amount of nonprofit organizations today. These include charitable, educational, religious, scientific, social and political organizations, among many others. (Did you know the NFL is a nonprofit?) Moreover, there are many nonprofits that resemble businesses (such as microfinance organizations, like KIVA) and nonprofits that maintain a close relationship with government. Keep in mind, when considering the nonprofit sector, that nonprofit interests, goals and activities constitute a very wide range (Renz, 2010).

References:
Berman, Howard J. 2002. Doing "Good" vs. Doing "Well": The Role of Nonprofits in Society. Inquiry 39: 5-11.

Renz, David O, ed. 2010. The Jossey-Bass Handbook of Nonprofit Leadership and Management. Jossey-Bass. San Francisco, CA.